What are some good sword fighting films

japanese vs. chinese sword fighting films

the japanese chambara (or jidaigeki) films have a very long tradition, which has its origins more or less completely in the no-theater or in the kabuki performances. And whether the fights and artistic capers shown in the films are actually presented more realistic, brutal or simply “faster” than in the Chinese films is an open question. Ultimately, it is also about spiritual attitudes, a corresponding code and, last but not least, also about historically connoted roots that play key roles in this. the comparison of japanese vs chinese sword fighting films is more reminiscent of the old apples vs pears comparison. In the end, it doesn't really make sense, as here and there very different (synthetic) origins play a role. so it's hard to say what is better or worse.

In any case, I found the shaw brothers films and I think they are pretty cool almost across the board. not only because of the action-packed sights, i also like these artificial structures and the whole studio atmosphere very much. I always liked that. and usually there is also a great score from one of the house and court composers there, who has also almost always fascinated me.

In contrast, the Japanese have a lot more naturalism to marvel at. just think of the classic akira kurosawa epics like “seven samurai”, “yojimbo” etc, or the samurai films by hideo gosha. They are something completely different in terms of their setting and, as already criticized above, cannot necessarily be compared with their Cantonese neighbors.

but it doesn't matter. for the files: “crouching tiger, hiden dragon” I found more so-so. In my opinion there was too much cramp and strained blabla to come across really effectively and grippingly. kitano has presented a nice update of the old series with his “zatoichi” film and yoji yamada recently showed with “twilight samurai” what formidable elegance is inherent in the genre.
"Hero" actually conveys a good deal of fascist ideology, which not only occurred in the sometimes very totalitarian mass scenes, fargo is right when he refers to corresponding remarks. Nevertheless, it's a great film, a veritable feast for the eyes, which you can enjoy as the essence of the cinema (as a form of pure movement and as a play of colors). the fight between jet li and donnie yuen zb is one of the most breathtaking things that cinema has produced in this direction in the last 20 years. so far….

--